Re: A CRM victory?

John A. Wise (wise_at_db.erau.edu)
Fri, 27 Sep 1996 14:04:15 -0800


>>>>>>>>>>>>> John Wise wrote <<<<<<<<<<<<<<
>>Why is everone moving on when there is an amazing amout of work to be done
>>in the CRM world. Has victory been declared based on empirically marginal
>>data and a new target chosen before anyone finds out? Almost sounds like a
>>Vietnam era press conference.
<<<<<<<<<<<<<< end snip >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>

>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> Reid Fairburn wrote <<<<<<<<<<<<<
> ==========John: I think that the use of CRM principals in the
>cockpit is in fact going to revolve around the use of the checklist. In
>abnormal situations where things can get hectic very fast...CRM is most
>important. All abnormals use some sort of checklist to get the ball
>rolling. Therefore, it is important to design the checklists correctly for
>use in a CRM situation. One for all and all for one kind of a situation...
<<<<<<<<<<<<< end snip >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>

My point (cleaverly hidden by my fantastic writing skills - or lack
thereof) was that how does anyone know whether any success has been
occurred after "person-centuries" of CRM training. People are running
around pushing this approach or that approach without any evidence that any
of it is having any affect.

I have deep reservations about the underpinnings of empirical support
offered for the effectiveness of what has been done to date. And if one
cannot measure the results in an sound way - then perhaps developing valid
measures is where we should be spending our resources.

John

John A. Wise, Ph.D., CHFP Tel: (+1) (904) 226-6384
Center for Aviation/Aerospace Research Fax: (+1) (904) 226-7050
Embry-Riddle Aeronautical University E-mail: wise_at_db.erau.edu
600 South Clyde Morris Blvd.
Daytona Beach, FL 32114-3900 USA