You have probably already considered this as an avenue of research, but =
if not, what about a questionaire directly to line crews who have worked =
through the creation and evolution of CRM. In the questionaire ask =
specifically how individuals viewed CRM: has it helped, and would they =
give examples of situations in which CRM prevented what may have =
otherwise resulted in an accident or incident. How many would respond =
is always the big question. However, if done properly and with the =
appropriate amount of anonimity, I think the results would be =
informative and of great value in answering the question you are dealing =
with. It may be that this type of study has already been done. If so, =
great. If not, I think this kind of first hand information from =
aircrews would be better than studies that look at related data and =
attempt to identify trends that may or may not be the result of CRM. =
Good Luck!
----------
From: Richard S. Jensen[SMTP:jensen.6_at_osu.edu]
Sent: Saturday, January 10, 1998 1:42 AM
To: crm-devel_at_db.erau.edu
Subject: Re: results
Tracy,
Dr. Al Diehl wrote a paper a while back on this topic:
Diehl, A. (1992, January). Does cockpit management training reduce =
aircrew
error? ISASI Forum, 24(4).
In Chapter 5 of my book, "Pilot Judgment and Crew Resource Management"
(available from Ashgate 802-276-3162), I go through the history of =
research
showing the effectiveness of judgment and CRM training. I continue to =
study
the topic here at OSU with support from the FAA.
Much more is needed and I think you have picked a great topic for you
graduate research. Please let me know how it goes. I hope to see your
results at the Symposium on Aviation Psychology some day.
Dick
At 09:40 PM 1/9/98 -0500, you wrote:
>
>CRMers,
>I am an A.C.T. (crm) instructor for the Navy's P-3 platform. Recently =
a
>perspective squadron C.O. during my C.O. brief stated to me that he =
really
>believed in the program BUT, wanted to know where is the proof that it
>works to convince those who don't believe. This was a difficult =
challenge.
> The Navy sells ACT as a tool to improve mission effectiveness, yet =
there
>are no studies that I am aware of that show this especially platform
>specific studies. I am taking this on as a challenge and have decided =
to
>make it my Graduate Research Project. Does anyone know of any =
existing
>research that may show a decrease in accidents since the introduction =
of
>CRM. I am looking for something that I could use as an example for
>research into the hypothesis that ACT has increased mission =
effectiveness
>in the P-3. Any ideas or help would be welcome.
> Lt Tracy Day=20
>
>
------ =_NextPart_000_01BD1D9C.A5806240
Content-Type: application/ms-tnef
Content-Transfer-Encoding: base64
eJ8+IgYMAQaQCAAEAAAAAAABAAEAAQeQBgAIAAAA5AQAAAAAAADoAAENgAQAAgAAAAIAAgABBJAG
ACQBAAABAAAADAAAAAMAADAFAAAACwAPDgAAAAACAf8PAQAAAEkAAAAAAAAAgSsfpL6jEBmdbgDd
AQ9UAgAAAABjcm0tZGV2ZWxAZGIuZXJhdS5lZHUAU01UUABjcm0tZGV2ZWxAZGIuZXJhdS5lZHUA
AAAAHgACMAEAAAAFAAAAU01UUAAAAAAeAAMwAQAAABYAAABjcm0tZGV2ZWxAZGIuZXJhdS5lZHUA
AAADABUMAQAAAAMA/g8GAAAAHgABMAEAAAAYAAAAJ2NybS1kZXZlbEBkYi5lcmF1LmVkdScAAgEL
MAEAAAAbAAAAU01UUDpDUk0tREVWRUxAREIuRVJBVS5FRFUAAAMAADkAAAAACwBAOgEAAAACAfYP
AQAAAAQAAAAAAAAFzjQBCIAHABgAAABJUE0uTWljcm9zb2Z0IE1haWwuTm90ZQAxCAEEgAEADAAA
AFJFOiByZXN1bHRzAAMEAQWAAwAOAAAAzgcBAAoABwAxADUABgBTAQEggAMADgAAAM4HAQAKAAcA
MQA1AAYAUwEBCYABACEAAAAyQ0RGMUU1ODhDODlEMTExQjQ2OTQ0NDU1MzU0MDAwMADsBgEDkAYA
kAkAABIAAAALACMAAAAAAAMAJgAAAAAACwApAAAAAAADADYAAAAAAEAAOQCAAD4/xh29AR4AcAAB
AAAADAAAAFJFOiByZXN1bHRzAAIBcQABAAAAFgAAAAG9HcY/JVge3zCJjBHRtGlERVNUAAAAAB4A
HgwBAAAABQAAAFNNVFAAAAAAHgAfDAEAAAARAAAAcmFwY29uQHN1bmV0Lm5ldAAAAAADAAYQjAh2
1wMABxAyCAAAHgAIEAEAAABlAAAAWU9VSEFWRVBST0JBQkxZQUxSRUFEWUNPTlNJREVSRURUSElT
QVNBTkFWRU5VRU9GUkVTRUFSQ0gsQlVUSUZOT1QsV0hBVEFCT1VUQVFVRVNUSU9OQUlSRURJUkVD
VExZVE9MSQAAAAACAQkQAQAAACIIAAAeCAAAog0AAExaRnWesvCV/wAKAQ8CFQKoBesCgwBQAvIJ
AgBjaArAc2V0MjcGAAbDAoMyA8UCAHByQnER4nN0ZW0CgzN3AuQHEwKAfQqACM8J2TvxFg8yNTUC
gAqBDbELYOBuZzEwMxRQCwoUUU0L8DQVcABAIFkIYCCREYB2ZSATUG9iAaCYbHkgB0AWEGFkG/CP
BaAAgQSBCYAgdGgEAC8cAB1xA6AbQW4KUCBvPGYgFhARsArAEXAsIAxidQVABpAgbm90fR8QdxGA
BUABoAhgICEgdnEKUBPAaQIgC3AWECASZCFRY3Qb4XRvIP5sC4AbYAUAB9AEIB/wIjA1GzN3BbBr
HRMDYHVnfmgdMSKDIBAhER2xHSBlHnYG8B9AJRIeYUNSTfAuICBJA6AkgiDLHZAwayBzcAWQBpBp
Y78HQBvhIxAH4AuAIZB2HNB+dQdABCApkAfQHREmYTq3JqARgAQgaQVAJJBsKFBOZB8QJVIjkHVs
HSJlDRvwZymAG2BleGFt7wtQB5EeYQCQdCnAIQIrAf8DoB/wKKAkYCZhG3ElkAnw/xPQK/EgAgDA
KPEbQh+wJJD+cgPxG2AekSwwL7IugR3C/mMocA2wAjAeUAXAC4AyhH0mkUgpIQOBG/AsFB6RcOcC
IDHhHXFsdzBQBCAkgrhiaWcgtzOkL3FyHxDdH3FkAiAbYyhQchviK+LzKyAkZGFwOCIHIRPQHAD9
BGB1MsIecABwAiAHcCsg6nkfEEkdMm4oICSCMXS7IuEsI2IbYAuAAhByAMC/IQAbUSVSHmEJwSAR
dgdAPx4xMgMD4AZxGRAm6yB5/xsBCsAhcRxAIlE2QDjyJpL/MCQ9MR1AIBEdQztQKFAtk/8t8Bxh
KuIcFj0wCfA3wyaS/S2xbx8QPpNF1B+jO5gdYf5rKVEeUiiQEaArMSVSPWf/JSEDUhwAIVAipTzm
PTACQP8EkELyA6BEIgiQNcIgERWgvm8oICARFhALYC+yZCAQ/yCgJVIgEBPRBTEiITKTBpD/IgEW
ECVgTMUwQgWxMEIfoTdCxDFWJihHTUAdIEx1+GNrIRnLDfAasgqFCosRIlAxODAC0WktMTw0NA3w
DNBW0wtZMTbPCqADYBPQIdAgLVj3Cof3V6sMMFh2RgNhKrBXj1iUvwyCB/Au0QsRBgAmkEoJ8AER
sG5bU01UUDpCal5zLjZAbzGQLvkJgHVdWZ9arQZgAjBb379c6wYQLfALIDBQHxBKAHAdKcByG/AZ
MB8QMTk5kjhlYDo0EeBBTWA/OVqtVG9if1zrBQBtLUMNsBtQbEBkYl/gcs5hX9Nmf2FOdWJfICHQ
e2ifXOxlKrA8VVT/VgMzXjZXd1RFWHYKhVRrUGNTO2BwzERyJpBBAyBE9QiQaAMgd1iCIJEKsDhR
/yCRLrEtYB8gANAoICUhQ1S7OEAooDp0nXXyHxBBJpAqKGWxMmTXKSaQRG+/B5EFoFOQeJAwIiEw
ZxPg/zKyUAALcT/iFhFTgCfhSpQnCoUEkANgcj8msFNBylM7kEYFsHVtHxAagNwoNHswcMwmwUMR
gAUwdUvhNR5SbUKxTUEfECLWUAMQUYFKREBnfJMlUr5DIrFwAUYwCHB9sU18R/oiCoUoG0ALcAtg
AmAbYGFKM0FzaGc6AlZgMkAtMjc2LTNYQDL6KTtyZyIwJAodUSIgZUH/HmkKhYcgKSA/5g3BIcEs
0fcicAQRHmFqg1svIXzmJpD/O5AckSEAHiIiIUQjCoUkgo94cytBJ9IFQE9TVTjknzGQOZAVsUok
JIJGQXog/XDMTVOAJGAEYCFhHWEicP8JgB0RJVI7lkDyGzQooCPC/yCgPpSQlD2BQOIKhQnAHFDv
LgExUx7DJpBQLWAdkBtg9y1gMCEbYGsfoAfgKRMFQP+IoAeQjpIjEEPBj2IJ4EDi/nIKhTxWQyMb
YAaxNPAAkBt/wHfiQSmQJPRQc3n7EXAVkWcb8EYwmtFkoYBdL3XgU5BwzAqFQQVAMDmNZhAwmhAv
MDEvOaSA8WXgLTA1VnAfEEDydkNdeMY+pfYmYQSQc3SGPo87kC0wHbJ6IEMuVHox/WpxKSlBE8B/
sCHQBbGYEqUkgk4bQHknBCBQiAD/G3BN0T2CJpFwEH2wAjAb4u+l9jhRKEI903MgwBxQA2D5gVEu
TyaQKbA/04JBrjP+YgiBRAJN4yIhmtFDAzwj/yjCpfY9MCJQL3Ex4ySCG4HjmPFKYEJVVB/RAHCw
Bf+bAx/wkQJDcrLUHmFDAysg/6X2I5J4UhyCKZAzMELiX7B3I3EjETfRJ1GSsiMmkVT/HVI1kB1x
IYEN0CigUlIRce8o0AnwfHCAVj65kapEnLHjKNAEIEFDVB2DIhEG8P9PMy1AA2AbUTswBBAlEov7
96UxmqEw4mWl9kEyH6BMXP+n5DWQIWG1xosyHTQ00Shh/yjDqxal9ihGTFYmkqfyAZD/SEFAAh1h
JSK6Err3JUMbM/8FgRzRsCKl9gDAI8ArEoJB/keZBoRhHsOaEANgbfImkf97VDQhN+KbAzqzG/At
EImh/z/hpfYellBow5O6MQWQHDH/MUEyAjJ1BCAAkLfEPUJQAP8EcKmBJfSmecbmTTI/4pgSv6Cy
O7JAAsIzBaAsMnUxQf8dlC0VmALPf9OBiLKJcUOw/zDSAJBMxb0SKuMzMNGzHSC/vq+MgqX2spWq
0SaRQTQxvxzRHZEFsStSPMgqQGwFoO8HgLuHXWNdY0xoUXRCdWCvMFGl/qJv5U8gFTEA5xAAAAMA
EBAAAAAAAwAREAIAAABAAAcwgHVn+MMdvQFAAAgwgAA+P8YdvQEeAD0AAQAAAAUAAABSRTogAAAA
AAsi
------ =_NextPart_000_01BD1D9C.A5806240--